Page 41 - ELG1804 Apr Issue 456
P. 41

RESOURCES                .                                                                                                                                                                                   REVIEWS & RESOURCES

                       Put a                                                                                                                                                                            Name: SEVERUS SNAPE
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Hogwarts Teachers:
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Pedagogical Profiles



             spell on                                                                                                                                                                                   Position: Potions Master

                                                                                                                                                                                                        Appearance: severe, long, black hair,
                                                                                                                                                                                                        dressed in black
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Strengths: has a
                                                                                                                                                                                                        commanding classroom
                                                                                                                                                                                                        presence
       your class                                                                                                                                                                                       Weaknesses: doesn’t
                                                                                                                                                                                                        believe in the capabilities
                                                                                                                                                                                                        of his pupilss, teacher-
                                                                                                                                                                                                        centred approach,
                                                                                                                                                                                                        discourages interaction


                                                                                                                                                                                                        Name: SYBILL TRELAWNEY
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Position: Head of Divination Workshop
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Appearance: unruly, long hair, thick-
                                                                                                                                                                                                        rimmed glasses, long and baggy clothes.
        Amanda Yesilbursa explains how Harry Potter’s                                                                                                                                                   Strengths: believes in learning by doing,
                                                                                                                                                                                                        sets up authentic, interactive activities,
        boarding school Hogwarts could hold the key to                                                                                                                                                  learner-centred approach
        better classroom interactions                                                                                                                                                                   Weaknesses: lacks an authoritative
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 presence, doesn’t always
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 listen to her students, appears
              wo years ago there were a series of   series had in the lives of some of my student-  preparing the schedule and material for a   OK, I know. Hogwarts teachers teach   First, there are plenty of them, and they   to be incompetent in her field
              events in my life that inspired me to   teachers.  Indeed, many of them had been   course on classroom interaction skills that I   magic, not English.   are varied and exist together within a single
              devise some slightly unusual teacher-  motivated to learn English in high school   was to teach for the first time.   But teachers of all subject matters display   context, which provides continuity.
        Ttraining techniques.                                                    Why not incorporate the interest in Harry     their beliefs about content, learning and   Second, the depictions of the teachers at
          First, my twins had reached the age where        Teachers of all      Potter and the images of teachers into my new   teaching in the way they set up interaction   Hogwarts are very stereotypical, even clichéd.   Name: GILDEROY LOCKHART
        they began to ‘get into’ J. K. Rowling’s Harry                          course? Why not support academic readings      in the classroom, and in the discourse they   Their behaviour and way of dressing, and   Position: Professor of Defence Against the
        Potter series, both the books and films.   subject matters display      on teachers’ beliefs and classroom interaction   choose, often unconsciously, to bring about   their subjects and methods of instruction fit in   Dark Arts
        Repeated readings and viewings ensued   their beliefs about             patterns with striking and engaging images of   learning.                          conveniently with other images of teachers in   Appearance: blond hair, sparkling smile,
        during the winter break. Revisiting the series                          familiar teachers?                               Anyway, who wouldn’t love to be able to   popular culture and literature.  superficially charming
        as a teacher-educator, I noticed the depictions   content, learning and   This way, it would be possible to tap into   cast an Accio Lingua Anglica spell and have   The teachers I generally choose to focus on   Strengths: attracts pupils’
        of the highly ritualised school environment                             shared conceptualisations of teachers. Video   their students fluent in English at the wave of   are Severus Snape, the potions master, Sybill   attention Weaknesses:
        and the teachers in particular.        teaching in the way              clips provide concrete, objective records of   a wand?                             Trelawney, head of the divination workshop,   self-important, boastful,
          The second event was the sad loss of                                  behaviour and its effects on others.             Although I originally had prospective   Gilderoy Lockhart, defence against the dark   showy, starts activities that
        Alan Rickman and the effect it had on   they set up interaction          Moreover, asking individuals to reflect       English language teachers in mind, the   arts professor, and Dolores Umbridge, high   he is unable to control,
        my prospective English language teachers.                               on the behaviour of fictitious teachers, such   activities I have developed are just as relevant   inquisitor.          incompetent
        January 2016 witnessed many gloomy faces in   in the classroom          as the Hogwarts teaching staff, can be less    for teachers of all levels of experience.  These characters provide sharp contrasts
        the department and laments on social media                              fraught with emotion than asking them to         So, exactly how do the Hogwarts teachers   – Snape is severe, Trelawney a little   Name: DOLORES JANE UMBRIDGE
        over the passing of ‘Severus Snape’.  because of Harry.                 talk critically about real teachers who have   help us to reflect on beliefs and classroom   dizzy, Lockhart narcissistic and Umbridge
          It struck home what an important place the   Third, while all this was going on, I was   had a significant role in their education.  interaction patterns?   authoritarian.                   Position: High Inquisitor, Headmistress
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Appearance: always wears pink, neat and
                                                                                                                                                                                                        tidy, dresses formally, superficial sweet
                                              n The appearance of the teacher    silly wand-waving or incantations in this      him and unwilling to speak out.     considered to the ‘real’ world of   appearance covers her cruel nature
             WORKING WITH                     n How s/he uses the classroom space  classroom.’ He remarks that potion-            At this point, participants can be led to   teaching. Prospective teachers are   Strengths: is organised, has a
                                              n The pupils’ reactions to the teacher  making is a ‘subtle science and an exact   think about a hypothetical authoritarian   encouraged to pay attention to the   commanding presence
                VIDEO CLIPS                   These points act as a springboard   art’ that he doesn’t expect many to           English language teacher who tells his/  points outlined above in the classrooms   Weaknesses: believes in teaching to the
                                             for guided observation, reflection and   ‘possess the disposition’ to master.      her students that some have the aptitude   of teachers they observe during      exam, doesn’t give importance
          ACTIVITY 1: LOOK                  discussion, with participants comparing   Taking this together with his severe     to learn a foreign language while others   teaching practice.                   to putting knowledge into use,
          This draws attention to the visual   notes on each teacher.            appearance – long black flowing                simply do not. S/he deliberately asks   Critical discussion can be encouraged   intolerant to challenges to her
         aspects of the videos only.          ACTIVITY 2: LISTEN                robes – and his intimidation of Harry          difficult questions to trip students   on the wider issues – teacher            authority
          The participants take notes on the                                     with questions about wormwood and              up and corrects everything that the   favouritism, reward and punishment,
         following points as they watch the short   This focuses on the discourse of each   bezoars, we can infer that Snape is an   students dare to utter.  What would the   the effects of examinations on teaching   Amanda Yesilbursa works
         clips of the first lessons of each Hogwarts   teacher. Participants are given the scripts   authoritarian figure who takes his subject   atmosphere be like in his/her classroom?   and learning, and even the stereotypical   as an English language
         teacher:                            of each clip, and are asked to highlight   matter very seriously.                  How would language learning be helped   representations of teachers in popular      teacher-educator at Uludag
          n The layout of the classroom      the words and phrases that reveal the   In fact he sees it as superior to any      or hindered?                        culture.                                        University, Turkey. This ar-
          n  What the pupils are doing before   respective teacher’s beliefs about subject   other school subject.               ACTIVITY 3:  CONNECT               In this way, teachers can develop skills       ticle was adapted from a talk
         the teacher arrives                 matter, learning and teaching.       He doesn’t believe that every child is                                            of observation and reflection in what           originally presented at the
          n How and from where the teacher    For example, Snape storms into the   able to learn how to make potions.             The final activity helps the participants   Umbridge calls ‘a secure, risk-free’   18th International INGED
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Conference in Istanbul,
         enters the classroom                classroom roaring, ‘There shall be no   This causes the pupils to be afraid of     to connect what they have seen and   environment.                                   Turkey, in October 2017.
        40                                                                                               April 2018            editorial@elgazette.com                                                                                41
   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43   44